The Ultimate Guide To Avoiding The 6 Biggest Divorce Mistakes

making-decisions-during-divorce-1024x768

This page may contain affiliate links. We only recommend products and services that we have tried, trust and love. For more information, you can read our terms and conditions.

Why Making Decisions During Divorce Feels Impossible (And What’s Actually Keeping You Stuck)

Making decisions during divorce is one of the hardest things you’ll ever do. You’ve read the books. Gone to therapy. Sat through marriage counseling. You’ve listened to podcasts, downloaded meditations, and had the same conversation with your best friend dozens of times.

And you’re still here. Uncertain. Circling. Questioning whether you’re making too much of this or not enough.

The problem isn’t that you need more information. Gathering more data, analyzing more carefully, waiting for the moment when you finally know enough…none of that is what’s going to move you forward. And somewhere underneath all the circling, you already know that.

For the high-achieving woman who has solved hard things in her life by preparing more, knowing more, and having the right strategy before she acts, this is a deeply disorienting place to be. That approach built your career. It built your life. It makes sense that you’re applying it here.

But marriage and divorce are different. Relationships have added layers that need to be taken into account. And the belief that figuring it out completely will finally let you act is exactly what’s keeping you stuck.

There’s a reason this keeps happening. And once you understand it, everything changes.

The Myth: If I Just Figure This Out Completely, I'll Be Able to Act

You’ve been saying some version of this for months. Maybe longer.

I need a little more time. I want to think about it. I just need to be sure.

And so you wait. You read two more books about relationships and divorce. You scroll Google at 2 a.m., searching for the one thing that will make it all click into place. You have another conversation with your best friend. You make another pros-and-cons list. You go back to therapy. You believe you are taking action. The problem is that no matter how much information you gather, the certainty you are waiting for never fully arrives. So you go back for more.

For someone who has earned every gold star, every promotion, every hard-won success by being the most prepared person in the room, it makes sense why you’d believe this is how you’ll figure it out. Knowing more before you act has never failed you. It’s the strategy that built your entire life.

But this can’t be solved by thinking more. And waiting for guarantees and certainty before making a decision, while it feels responsible and productive, is keeping you stuck. Because if you act and it was a mistake, you failed. And if you don’t act, and that was the mistake, you failed. But if you don’t make a final decision, your mind believes you can’t fail. And for someone who spent her entire life working to not fail at all costs, choosing wrong is not an option.

As a recovering perfectionist, I’ve noticed a sneakier fear underneath all of it. What if you actually get what you want? Because if you do, you’ll have to become the woman who has the life she always dreamed of. Your current reality is challenging. But you know how to manage challenges. Receiving everything you ever wanted, that’s terrifying. Because who do you have to become to have that life?

The Real Cost of Not Trusting Yourself During Divorce

You think you’re doing the right thing, and you are. But while you’ve been gathering, analyzing, and waiting, you’ve been losing sleep. Snapping at your kids. Unable to concentrate at work.

You feel frustrated. Resentful. Deeply unhappy. But instead of acknowledging those feelings and moving through them, you set them aside. Because everyone else’s comfort has always felt more important than yours. So the feelings build and fester. Eventually, they find their way out in a moment of rage or sobbing when you’re at the grocery store or about to lead a meeting.

Your shoulders are tight, and you’re always on edge. So you pour an extra glass of wine or scroll Facebook to take the edge off. At some point, you stop noticing you’ve gone absent, even though you’re right there. Your kids notice. Your work notices. You notice, somewhere underneath it all, and that awareness just adds to the guilt and shame you’ve been feeling. 

And that’s the cruelest part of all. The clarity you’ve been waiting for, the certainty you keep searching for, it can’t reach you from inside all of that. Not because it isn’t there. Because you’re too closed, too braced, too exhausted to let it in. You’ve been waiting for the answer to arrive. But you haven’t been in a state where you could receive it even if it did.

Change happens at the speed of safety.

Knowledge is power, but at some point, gathering data can become too much. You have everything you need, but it doesn’t feel like enough. Because change doesn’t happen only because you want it. It happens when your mind and body are in sync. And if your body isn’t on board, no amount of information or strategy will feel like enough. A body that doesn’t feel safe won’t allow it, no matter how much you understand intellectually what needs to happen.

This is why you take two steps forward and three steps back. You get yourself ready. You work up the courage. You think you know what you want, and you go for it. And the moment you step toward something different, your nervous system does exactly what it was designed to do. It senses the unknown. It registers danger. It does everything it can to bring you back to what’s familiar. Not because you made a mistake. Not because your clarity was wrong. Because your system is doing its job. It’s employee of the month, every month.

This isn’t a willpower problem. It isn’t a clarity problem. It isn’t even an information problem. It’s a safety problem.

Internal safety allows the unfamiliar to become familiar. And once it feels familiar, you can move toward something new without your system sounding the alarm. You begin to move differently. Not because the fear disappears.

Because it stops leading.

Why Making Decisions During Divorce Isn't a Data Problem

My client Laura*, an oncologist, spends her days synthesizing complex data, making high-stakes decisions, and trusting her judgment in situations where the margin for error is razor-thin. That’s not just her job. It is who she is.

When it came to her marriage, she did what she always does. She researched. She gathered information. She sought opinions. She analyzed. She waited for the data to produce the clarity it always had before.

But certainty never came.

Not because she hadn’t done enough work. She had more than enough data. What she didn’t yet have was safety. She could trust herself to make life-or-death decisions for her patients. When it came to her own life, she froze.

Once she learned to create internal safety, she began to trust what she already knew. The answer had been there for a long time. Her system just hadn’t felt safe enough to act on it.

Trusting Yourself During Divorce Is a Gift You Give Yourself

Creating internal safety isn’t something you’re born with. It’s something you learn. It’s a skill that must be practiced and honed. And no one is teaching you how. You don’t learn this in high school, college, or grad school. And yet it’s the most important piece to building a life that doesn’t just look good but feels good.

Building internal safety means learning to notice when your system starts to sound the alarm, and instead of retreating back to the familiar or pushing through and white-knuckling it, you pause. You use specific tools and practices to settle your system. And then you take one small step forward. Not a leap. A step. Then you pause again. Let your system settle. And repeat.

Every time you do this, something shifts. The unfamiliar starts to feel a little less threatening. Your nervous system learns that the unknown is survivable. That you can move toward something different without being destroyed by it. That fear doesn’t have to mean stop.

Over time, the life you’ve been too afraid to want starts to feel possible. 

This is the work we do inside LIBERATED. Not by pushing you toward a decision or telling you what your life should look like. By teaching you how to build the internal safety that makes trusting yourself during divorce feel less like a leap of faith and more like the most natural next step you’ve ever taken.

Your Next Step

You’ve been trying to figure this out long enough.

You don’t need more information. You don’t need another book or another pros-and-cons list. You need someone who can help you build the internal safety to trust what you already know.

That’s exactly what we do together.

If you’re ready to stop spinning and start moving forward in a way that actually feels steady, let’s talk about how you can use divorce as a launchpad for your reinvention.

Picture of Sharri Freedman

Sharri Freedman

Let’s use divorce as a launchpad for your reinvention.
My signature LIBERATED Methodology is a science-based, proven approach that helps you think clearly, trust your choices, and move forward without regret. When your nervous system settles and your mind quiets, the answers rise with ease. They’ve always been there.
You just couldn’t hear them until now.

Services Page Hero Image
Hi, I'm Sharri!
Sharri Freedman

Attorney, Reinvention Coach, & Divorce Expert

Combining 30+ years of legal wisdom and experience with nervous system regulation, mindset, somatics, and subconscious reprogramming, I’ll guide you through divorce and the reinvention that follows so you can trust yourself under pressure, make decisions without regret, and stop abandoning yourself to keep everyone else comfortable.

Whether you’re contemplating divorce, in the thick of it, or already on the other side, I’ll help you stop waiting for certainty and start looking forward to who you get to become.

Let's Connect!
Blog Categories
The Ultimate Guide To Avoiding The 6 Biggest Divorce Mistakes
Lead Magnet Mockup

Happiness Hits

Looking for a weekly dose of Happiness?

Subscribe to my weekly Happiness Hits for Women contemplating, going through, or rebuilding after divorce. Because no matter what is happening on the outside you are ALWAYS worthy of happiness.